These are the production numbers for S54-engined M Coupe color combinations produced for North America in order of commonality.

Total Production: 678 (110 sunroof-delete)

2001: 338 (61 sunroof-delete)
2002: 340 (49 sunroof-delete)

Titanium Silver Metallic (190, 30 sunroof-delete)

Black Nappa (132, 19 sunroof-delete)
Dark Gray & Black Nappa (32, 2 sunroof-delete)
Imola Red & Black Nappa (16, 5 sunroof-delete)
Laguna Seca Blue & Black Nappa (6, 3 sunroof-delete)
Estoril Blue & Black Nappa (4, 1 sunroof-delete)

Steel Gray Metallic (121, 18 sunroof-delete)

Black Nappa (47, 5 sunroof-delete)
Dark Gray & Black Nappa (46, 8 sunroof-delete)
Imola Red & Black Nappa (23, 2 sunroof-delete)
Estoril Blue & Black Nappa (3, 2 sunroof-delete)
Kiwi & Black Nappa (2, 1 sunroof-delete) - pre-production

Black Sapphire Metallic (120, 11 sunroof-delete)

Black Nappa (74, 8 sunroof-delete)
Dark Beige Oregon (17, 1 sunroof-delete)
Imola Red & Black Nappa (17, 1 sunroof-delete)
Dark Gray & Black Nappa (10, 1 sunroof-delete)
Laguna Seca Blue & Black Nappa (2, 0 sunroof-delete)

Estoril Blue (75, 21 sunroof-delete)

Estoril Blue & Black Nappa (51, 13 sunroof-delete)
Black Nappa (13, 6 sunroof-delete)
Dark Gray & Black Nappa (11, 2 sunroof-delete)

Imola Red (67, 13 sunroof-delete)

Imola Red & Black Nappa (41, 9 sunroof-delete)
Black Nappa (19, 1 sunroof-delete)
Dark Gray & Black Nappa (4, 2 sunroof-delete)
Dark Beige Oregon (3, 1 sunroof-delete)

Laguna Seca Blue (41, 6 sunroof-delete)

Dark Gray & Black Nappa (21, 2 sunroof-delete)
Laguna Seca Blue & Black Nappa (16, 3 sunroof-delete)
Black Nappa (2, 0 sunroof-delete)
Estoril Blue & Black Nappa (1, 0 sunroof-delete)
Dark Beige Oregon (1, 1 sunroof-delete)

Alpine White (31, 4 sunroof-delete)

Black Nappa (21, 1 sunroof-delete)
Dark Beige Oregon (4, 0 sunroof-delete)
Dark Gray & Black Nappa (2, 0 sunroof-delete)
Imola Red & Black Nappa (2, 2 sunroof-delete)
Estoril Blue & Black Nappa (1, 1 sunroof-delete)
Alpine White & Black Nappa (1, 0 sunroof-delete) – Last Produced

Phoenix Yellow Metallic (21, 3 sunroof-delete)

Black Nappa (17, 2 sunroof-delete)
Dark Gray & Black Nappa (3, 1 sunroof-delete)
Laguna Seca Blue & Black Nappa (1, 0 sunroof-delete)

Oxford Green II Metallic (10, 4 sunroof-delete)

Dark Beige Oregon (6, 2 sunroof-delete)
Black Nappa (4, 2 sunroof-delete)

Special Ordered (2, 0 sunroof-delete)

Black Nappa (2, 0 sunroof-delete)
- LK60168 – Carbon Black
- LK61334 – Dakar Yellow

Interior Colors

Black Nappa (331, 44 sunroof-delete)
Dark Gray & Black Nappa (129, 18 sunroof-delete)
Imola Red & Black Nappa (99, 19 sunroof-delete)
Estoril Blue & Black Nappa (60, 17 sunroof-delete)
Dark Beige Oregon (31, 5 sunroof-delete)
Laguna Seca Blue & Black Nappa (25, 6 sunroof-delete)
Kiwi & Black Nappa (2, 1 sunroof-delete) – only on pre-production S54 coupes

If you wonder where I get all my production numbers, they were collected by a Bimmerforums member wildag (www.dreamingwell.com).  The original CSV file can be downloaded here.  Another forum member has created a more user friendly database interface for the less technically inclined at: www.bmwmdata.com.  This set of data includes all North American M Coupes and Roadsters with their production dates and options.